Jason Castro continues to be my favorite American Idol contestant. He doesn’t have the best pure tone or range. For those, you likely want to look to Carly Smithson on the women’s side. But the boy with the long eyelashes and longer dreds better go up-tempo soon, even if it’s emo, because the angst and fluttery vocals make him a great stylist, and I want to watch him for another month or two before Smithson and perhaps Ramiele knock him out of the finals. For pure musicianship, though, I’m really like David.
That’s my problem with picking a winner. As Simon Cowell told a contestant last night, “You’ll do fine as long as this remains a talent competition and not a popularity contest.” Take that, Taylor Hicks. But Simon was talking about narrowing the scope to which singer had the best stage presence or could deliver the best live vocals of pop music and its billion genres. If this were truly a vocal competition, Julliard and a handful of conservatories would have sent opera singers. This is a pop/rock/R&B/more music/less talk competition. And with those contests come the futtery eyebrows, the sassy attitudes, the Elvis hip shake, Beatle cuts, glam rock and rapper battles.
I face the same issues when I play in my fantasy baseball league. I’ve been doing that since there was a Rotisserie League. The core group of guys I play with — perhaps five in all — have been doing this together for 23 years. I quit at the end of last year because of a spat over rules, mostly because I was tired of rules. Then again, I finished third (the rule was over a tie for 2nd instead of third, and the difference in money may have been enough for dinner two at Applebee’s). I collected a nice payday. Great, I”ve done that three times in 23 years. I’m a little behind because I always lose.
Why?
I spent the first 15 years playing the game as a baseball fan would, picking players I enjoyed watching who did lots of intangibles like a catcher backing up a play at first or a second baseman with great range who knew how to play baserunners and the batter simultaneously. Hit behind the runner when you’re down 1-0 in the 8th with no one out, and you have won my admiration.
Except those players don’t do well in fantasy baseball. The guy who hits 21 homeruns while batting in the 6 spot as a DH and who doesn’t break .250 does well. It’s only recently that I began to even appreciate those players when I’m playing the game. And that, rather than the rules, led more to my disillusionment than anything else.
So how am I to process the banner ad I just saw for a fantasy fishing contest. I’m sure there are folks who love to watch that activity, and I’m sure there are plenty of intangibles. I just find it amazing that you can find others willing to dedicate hours every year for decades on the right mix.
I don’t think fantasy fishing will last, but I sure hope the people playing that game enjoy it like I used to enjoy the baseball version. I agreed to play another year. It’s March 12, and the draft is in 2 weeks. I haven’t looked at anything related to baseball in almost six months. Maybe I’ll actually pick up the 2008 equivalent of Gorman Thomas or Dave Kingman.